Piero Savastano
New Revelations About OpenAI (the Board and Jony Ive)

New Revelations About OpenAI (the Board and Jony Ive)

May 25, 2025
5 min read
Table of Contents
index

I highly recommend this article in The Atlantic. It covers the period when the nonprofit board of OpenAI turned against Sam Altman, and it looked like they had managed to push him out. Then, after two or three days, Altman was back as CEO, the others were left empty-handed, as we say in Rome, and some months later both Sutskever and Murati actually left.

I always wondered what really happened in there.

Research vs commercialization

Clearly, at some point enormous tensions built up. The research side of OpenAI, the genuinely nonprofit part, was oriented toward building ever stronger models, doing more and more basic research, and it was very committed to alignment and safety research.

The article describes Ilya Sutskever as the head of research, a student of Hinton, the Nobel laureate in physics. Sutskever is the genius of the story, and he was also a bit paranoid: he talked about bunkers to protect themselves once they created AGI, artificial general intelligence.

There are fascinating revelations, and the article details the conflict between Sutskever, Mira Murati - more of an executive personality, and very capable - and Altman, who apparently pitted people against each other and made liberal use of lies. That doesn’t surprise me at all: watch him talk for five minutes and it’s one piece of nonsense after another. Look at what Altman did before OpenAI too. A classic turbo-capitalist.

So there was the research faction, and there was the faction of Altman and others - including Microsoft, which had invested - that wanted to commercialize as aggressively as possible.

The Jony Ive acquisition

Lately there’s also been talk of the acquisition of the startup of Jony Ive, the former Apple designer of international fame. I hear lots of influencers describing the news as: “Guys, something amazing happened, OpenAI acquired this startup with Ive in it, the one who made the iPhone with Steve Jobs, so we’ll use AI through new devices.”

I see a strange flow of money in there. Nobody says it, and I don’t understand why. OpenAI is a nonprofit - I don’t know whether it has already become, or will become, a benefit corporation, half and half - but it’s hard for OpenAI to get money out of there unless they come up with something.

We already had a taste of these mega-acquisitions with Windsurf, for which they paid 3 billion. Now they gave Ive something like six, I think, one way or another. These are mostly exchanges of equity rather than cash. But these valuations, and the slices of these startups that get sold, actually flow back into the circle of investors, and if you look into those investors, the trail of where the money goes fades a bit.

My idea - half conspiracy theory, granted, but thinking the worst never hurts - is that this was a bit of a trick to get money out of OpenAI. Both Windsurf and this deal are ways to put money into the pockets of a whole series of people who are blocked by the fact that OpenAI is a nonprofit, or was until very recently.

There are no revolutionary devices, no AI always with you. Humane and Rabbit R1 already tried, and the worst garbage came out. Sure, maybe at some point they’ll make some device, something. But in my opinion this is all about money, it has nothing to do with an AI device. Also because if the acquisition makes so much noise and there’s no prototype, no demo, nothing, I’m not falling for it at all.

Back to the board

Going back to the conflict between Sutskever and Altman: when Altman was fired by the board on the initiative of Sutskever and Murati, OpenAI apparently fractured and split, partly because there were large compensation packages, equity that could be converted - I didn’t fully understand that part. Meanwhile Altman had made promises about money, and Sutskever wasn’t able to hold the place together. Maybe Murati could have, but Murati herself was under a thousand pressures. Microsoft was obviously the bogeyman in the background of all this. And they reinstated Altman, who won.

The myth of the salesman

Every time I see Altman going around talking about artificial intelligence, I think: does this guy understand anything at all about AI? When I hear the kids on TikTok, YouTube and Instagram saying “ChatGPT was invented by Altman” - what are you talking about?

It’s like Steve Jobs: we build a myth around the person who commercializes. That can be fine - he’s an entrepreneurial talent, a commercial talent - but if you really want to talk about who invented, who discovered this stuff, you have to look somewhere else entirely.

The bitter takeaway is that these characters apparently have the last word. Altman is still there, and all I can do is hope that in the future he gets paid back for the deceptive strategies, the lies, and the way he took what was a great project and turned it into selling potatoes.